Lessons On Governance From The Internet

The internet, along with the personal computers that allow us access to it, are by far the most important innovations of our era. The ubiquitous instantaneous access to the information riches of cyberspace and to communication between people anywhere, has changed the world so fundamentally in just a few decades, that we sometimes forget how profound their impact has been. The information revolution birthed by the internet is one of those true epochal shifts, like the industrial revolution and the development of agriculture.

We should reflect more about the remarkably rapid success of the internet and what made that success possible. In our thinking about how to rebuild and restructure our economy, we should pay more attention to the most dramatic and fundamental success of our era.

The internet was birthed as a research project by the US government, specifically the US Department of Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency. But unlike most things the government has been involved with, it was created with no hierarchy, no rules, no governing structure and no bureaucracy. Instead the users at the four universities that started the network used a process of respectful consensus to develop the necessary standards of participation in order to enable the network to function. And that initial very libertarian governing  culture of the internet from the 1960s has somehow managed to mostly survive, even as the internet itself has evolved to be a global system that in many ways has become the foundation for the underlying architecture and ecology of information on the planet.

In “How the Internet Got Its Rules”, Stephen Crocker, author of the very first “Request for Comments” describes how that very modest means of communication between colleagues became the standard for rule making and establishing governing protocols on the internet.

Crocker suggests that: “Instead of authority-based decision-making, we relied on a process we called ‘rough consensus and running code.’ Everyone was welcome to propose ideas, and if enough people liked it and used it, the design became a standard”. He adds “that culture of open processes was essential in enabling the Internet to grow and evolve as spectacularly as it has.”

Crocker goes on to modestly suggest that “as we rebuild our economy, I do hope we keep in mind the value of openness.”

That is the most fundamental lesson of the internet. Unfortunately it seems to be the lesson most completely lost on those in high places trying to engineer a heavy handed government managed design of a new economy.


1 Comment

Filed under Fundamental Perspectives

One response to “Lessons On Governance From The Internet

  1. Jo Lee

    I saw that oped in the NY Times as well. But my experience as the director of communications for VocalTec -the company that invented voice over the Internet (VoIP) and the poster child of the industry for many years – was quite different. Creating standards to manage a highly sophisticated network of streaming audio packets over a young and immature Internet was a highly competitive, cut-throat process. Lots of money was at stake and the big players – Cisco, MS… – wielded way more power than the little guys – like VocalTec. We were forced to invest a big chunk of our resources and effectively used the press to make sure the playing field remained more even. I think it’s naive to think that this will be a gentleman’s endeavor. Brace yourself for lots of jockeying for position and alliances forming and dissolving. My .02

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s